Cheap Labor Debate
The cheap labor debate is an excellent topic for a business or MBA research paper. You will want to explore both sides of the issue in your research and explain the merits of each.
While some believe cheap labor such as sweatshops are morally wrong, others believe that these structures serve a positive function because they help other, more desolate countries earn a living. In order to appropriately consider the argument, it is important not to simply dismiss one perspective. A full exploration of both sides must be considered in an effort to ultimately mediate the situation. It can be illustrated that mediating the situation could allow for a mutually beneficial experience which both allows the multinational enterprise to enjoy cheaper labor, while still allowing the off-site location to utilize an opportunity to allow them to grow and prosper with freedom, respect and dignity.
Cheap Labor Debate - Cheap Labor
Many people associate cheap labor with a disregard and disrespect of individuals. For example, Dennis G. Arnold and Norman E. Bowie, authors of "Sweatshops and Respect for Persons", believe that multinational enterprises are actually inherently responsible for certain objectives at foreign manufacturing operation sites. These include:
- Following local labor laws
- Prohibiting coercion
- Implementing at least the minimum safety standards
- Providing a wage to employees that allows them to earn a living.
They believe that human dignity and human rights are inherent to such situations. The authors point out the argument by Amartya Sen, which states that the development of an area requires more than improve income for the residents and a more agreeable Gross National Product average. Of particular importance is the freedom of the worker, who is allowed freedom by their work.
Cheap labor, particularly cheaper labor for the enterprise investing in off-site production, does not necessitate that managers and organizations choose to either forgo human rights and human dignity or forego helping developing regions. Investing in cheap labor in a foreign or developing region should be done with the best interests of the stakeholders in mind, which includes both investors and the potential employees. If a business cannot invest in a cheaper labor opportunity to the mutual benefit of the potential employees by following through with what Arnold and Bowie have expressed as their responsibilities and duties as multinational enterprises, the company should consider remaining within their regional comfort zone. As the authors point out in their follow-up article "Respect for Workers in Global Supply Chains: Advancing the Debate over Sweatshops", "competent managers could meet their duties to workers" without sacrificing their other stakeholders and investors. The authors further their argument in their second article; it is not likely that paying employees a living wage for a 48 hour work week, which is still considerably lower in developing nations, would cause the enterprises to buckle and fold.
Cheap labor does not necessitate sweatshops. Investing in cheap labor, not sweatshop labor, could be both morally agreeable and mutually beneficial to the employees and the organization. The situation is not nearly as black and white as many debaters might project. Understanding the fundamental reality of the situation, foreign employees in developing countries do not have the same, arguably higher standard of living as the country of origin for the multinational enterprise might possess. A minimal increase would meet the duties of the multinational enterprise from a moral and ethical standpoint, while still allowing the host countries to benefit and grow in a respectful environment.
Related Research Paper Topic Suggestions
American Federation of Labor - American Federation of Labor research papers delve into the history of the organization’s foundation through its merger with the Congress of Industrial Organizations.
Capital and Labor According To Karl Marx - Capital and Labor According to Marx research papers focus on the philosophy of Karl Marx in relation to the proletariat and the bourgeoisie.
Capitalism and slavery - Capitalism and Slavery research papers overview the economic reasons behind slavery. Often the text by Eric Williams, Capitalism and Slavery, is used and cited.
Division of Labor - Division of Labor research papers discuss the labor strategy, employed during the early development of the Industrial Revolution, where individuals perform specific tasks and take on various roles.
Feminization of Labor In Pakistan - Feminization of Labor in Pakistan Research Papers look at a sample of an order placed on an economics project that has specific source requirements. Economics Research Papers at Custom Written.
History of Labor Day - History of Labor Day Term Papers discuss how this national holiday came about and the founders. Learn more about United States history from the writers at Paper Masters.
International Labor Organization - The International Labour Organization research papers discuss the United Nations agency that works with member nations in order to promote labor standards and decent work for all.
Paterson Silk Strike of 1913 - The Paterson Silk Strike of 1913 Research Papers account for one of the most startling labor movements during the industrialization.
Sweatshops - Sweatshops Research Papers discuss the issue of sweatshops and outsourcing as it pertains to the fashion industry.